Re: Shades of Egan's Diaspora

From: CurtAdams@aol.com
Date: Wed May 08 2002 - 20:06:13 MDT


In a message dated 5/8/02 18:02:12, bradbury@aeiveos.com writes:

>The article also
>ignores that nature has the capability to evolve much more radiation
>tolerant genomes that we mere humans have. Selection pressure
>can compensate for the hazard function to a limited extent.

Well, it could if it came more often than every 100 million years.
The "oh, this explains mass extinctions" is very iffy, since the
Cretaceous is associated with a monster asteroid, the mid-Cambrian
with glaciers at the equator, the Permian with a comet *and* a
cooling earth, and I just saw a presentation a few months ago claiming
one of the other (Ordovician?) is artefactual. Not much to be explained.

Like you, I'm a little skeptical. Space is so huge - even exploding
stars don't do all that much. Hopefully some informed astronomers
will put some counterarguments on the table soon.



This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Sat Nov 02 2002 - 09:13:55 MST