From: O'Regan, Emlyn (Emlyn.ORegan@actew.com.au)
Date: Wed Oct 13 1999 - 01:34:10 MDT
Ladies & Jellybeans,
I came across the idea of a canonical list of texts a while back (on
Transhumantech)? The idea is to set up a centralised database on the web, of
reading lists for every conceivable discipline/science/area of interest. It
would need to be updated by netizens as they saw fit; people with specific
knowledge of a particular area would be able to add/update/criticize reading
lists regarding their area(s) of specialty.
Anyone who has studied anything (bookish) has had the experience of finding
useless books on subjects, finding mediocre books, and finding the essential
(canonical) texts to which one will refer as the final arbiter on that
subject. For instance, I have a shelf full of computer science & maths
texts, some of which I cannot live without (in a professional sense).
What I find irritating is that when I want to move into a different field
(say physics), how do I begin? What is the definitive "introduction" book?
Where do I go from there. How about if I know a bit about waves/particles,
and a bit of maths, what would be the best book(s) to get me up to speed on
nuclear physics? Often, if you haven't gone into the subject in enough depth
(true by definition for the beginner), you don't even know what questions to
ask to find out where to start, so a web search for this hazy grail is
incredibly lengthy and probably fruitless.
What would be useful is something like an annotated master catalog of
university course reading lists. Sometimes the texts are inferior or hard to
come by, but its a good approximation to a canonical texts list. Also I
notice there are lists kicking around the net, but they seem quite
specialised, and without much annotation (just a list of books).
Does anyone know if the canonical texts database exists? If so, where? If
not, how close an approximation is out there?
Thanks all & sundry
Emlyn
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Fri Nov 01 2002 - 15:05:30 MST