From: Damien Broderick (damien@ariel.ucs.unimelb.edu.au)
Date: Thu Aug 27 1998 - 17:56:38 MDT
I hope you'll all forgive me if I treat the list for a moment as an
intellectual resource to be plundered. Specifically, I suddenly realised
that there's a bizarre hole right in the middle of my layperson's grasp of
elementary molecular biology.
Everyone knows that DNA is prey to mutations, most of them quickly edited
out by vigilant repair mechanisms, most of the rest neutral or bad news,
only a few improving the genes they happen to occur within. But by what
chemical pathway do those mutations come about? I'd always assumed that
most of them involved gross *deletions* of one or more nucleotide bases,
the implication being that the least dangerous deletion would knock out
three adjacent bases in one go (otherwise *all* the subsequent three-letter
codons are fouled). However, many mutations occur at a single point. The
classic instance is the change creating sickle cell anaemia, in which
position 6 in the 146 amino acid chain has valine instead of glutamic acid.
Presumably this means that an adenine has been changed into a uracil (or,
in the DNA chain, into a thymine).
But how the hell does the equivalent of a random impact do that?
It struck me that this is about as obvious as finding that a WIFE can be
mistaken for a HAT. Well, that a WIFE can be turned into a WIG.
I'd like to draw you little pictures of the bases at this point, but it's
too hard in email. My point is that this mutation calls for a purine
double ring to be changed deftly into a pyramidine single ring, with all
manner of small but precise replacements of Ns and Os and Hs. I'm sure
such things *can* happen by chance, but it looks as if it would have to be
either a cumulative process (ruled out by the way DNA copying occurs, I'd
imagine) or a strange event akin to four eccentrically-clad skaters running
into each other and rebounding, leaving the guy in the middle dressed in a
dinner suit.
Any advice for the perplexed?
Damien Broderick
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Fri Nov 01 2002 - 14:49:31 MST