From: John K Clark (johnkc@well.com)
Date: Wed Mar 11 1998 - 12:09:56 MST
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
On Wed, 11 Mar 1998 "Alexander 'Sasha' Chislenko" <sasha1@netcom.com> Wrote:
>You can be unhappy punishing anybody, but the criminals will also be
>unhappy. That's the point - their unhappiness with the punishment
>will prevent them from committing [more] crime.
Exactly, preventing future crime is the only reason for punishment, or at
least the only reason I would care to defend. My point was that if you're
going to kill a murderer anyway then you can be sure he will never kill again
so there is no purpose in torturing him before you do so.
Ok, an argument could be made about increasing the deterrent, but this effect
may not exist (it would probably just generate sympathy in the population for
the murderer and make him a martyr) however even if it did and the effect was
proven to be large I still wouldn't go for it because emotional revulsion
against torture would prevent me. Hey, I never said I was a paragon of logic.
>Calibrating people's psychological perceptions does sound like an
>insurmountable problem, but it is never taken into account.
>Calibrating physical effects, such as tiredness and pain, is
>extremely easy compared to that. So by your very argument, we should
>abandon all other types of punishment in favor of the corporal.
Tiredness and pain are psychological perceptions, heart failure, shock, and
massive blood loss are physical effects. You'd be giving one person a mild
irritation, a second person a lifelong crippling injury, and a third person a
death sentence, and all for committing the exact same crime.
John K Clark johnkc@well.com
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: 2.6.i
iQCzAgUBNQbhHn03wfSpid95AQH/qgTvV8pdgCh/2dIgbwujvF9yCVHXBSp0FLZR
LQ3pAYYkUQijCuEw7XH436bxwszhEulcW9aXm3Ss2WcG68TTZIQwj6nEsalUAfNe
uR2BAqou7qsmQ3+7Kutf7rDUThYgHK9F1a98Ed3m4IOA4jF8se0b3pJn3fj7wzZI
ccBngQVz30gLToYuz9xx9naTmJg6YBxzdwibKEwxGX5L5tYPPRU=
=r75z
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Fri Nov 01 2002 - 14:48:43 MST