From: Twink (neptune@mars.superlink.net)
Date: Thu Nov 20 1997 - 17:49:11 MST
At 05:06 PM 11/20/97 -0500, Keith Elis <hagbard@ix.netcom.com> wrote:
>> I understand. It was merely a suggestion. Recall my initial post.
>> Some people outside this list agree with you -- viz., that uplifting
>> is akin to trapping a human mind in a nonhuman (less than
>> human?) body.
>
>No, no. I'm not talking about uplifting, which I find to be pretty fascinating.
>I'm talking about a mere cross-breed of chimp and human. What would be
>the purpose other than to show that a cross-breed is possible?
Again: cheap, quick way to uplift. It's kind of like the poor man's uplift
experiment.:)
>> What standard do we
>> use to judge?
>
>The question is better put, what standard do *you* use to judge? Moral
relativism
>is serving me well these days...
Then, it is not wrong _objectively_ to you to cross-breed?
>But scientists do have ethical guidelines for themselves. Unfortunately, they
>don't help much when you're stuck in the middle of a gray area.
Guidelines are not perfect.
>> >>1. Will crossbreeding chimps and humans help us augment human beings?
>>
>> I believe my initial post answers this question. The data from it will
>> also give us more parameters on just how far intelligence can be
>> stretched inside the biotic realm.
>
>If your above suggestion is true (not just hand-waving), then it may be a valid
>reason. I don't want to argue the merits, but suffice it to say, if I were
>deciding funding, I'd need some pretty good evidence.
Understood. I actually think crossbreeding would not help much. It would
be too
random/chaotic. I doubt it would produce viable much less fertile
offspring. The
only reason I went on with this was to clear up matters in my own head. I do
think, though, that uplifting chimps by other methods might prove helpful in
augmenting humans. Also, I suspect, a lot of the developmental patterns are
similar between apes and humans, such that insertion of genetic sequences
might have similar effects in both.
Daniel Ust
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Fri Nov 01 2002 - 14:45:08 MST