From: Enigl@aol.com
Date: Sat Mar 15 1997 - 06:12:56 MST
In a message dated 97-03-13 23:07:25 EST, you write:
<< You said I was conveniently forgetting about an article Gallo published in
Science in 1983.
>>
No. Do you _read_ my posts? After reading your last post. I see you didn't
learn much about reading scientific papers from my attempt to teach you. So,
I have failed. You said Gallo "himself" argues for HTLV-I and then quote
statements that oppose that (your own) contention. Illogical.
And BTW, I did not say Gallo, I said the 1983 Pasteur Institute paper by
Barre-Sinoussi, et. al. , not Gallo, but I'm repeating myself:
<<Subj: Re: HIV=/=AIDS Video
Date: 03/09/97
To: extropians@extropy.org
<<. . . in 1983 not 1984", you are wrong. Do you follow that? >>
1. I claimed the Pasteur Institute's Barre-Sinoussi, et. al. (not Gallo) in
1983. Do you follow that? Gallo et. al. published in 1984 with HTLV-III
(not HTLV-I).
2. Gallo _never_ claimed HTLV-I caused AIDS, not 1983 and not 1984.>>
. . . and not in 1986 and not in 1997. You quote statements agreeing with me
then turn right around and claim the statements oppose what I am saying.
Illogical. I think it has been a waste of my time communicating with you.
I am sorry spending so much time working on this. It is a lesson for me, to
let other people alone, especially if they appear to have already made up
their minds, because, in that case, logic and written documentation is not
enough.
Davin C. Enigl, (Sole Proprietorship) MEAS
President-Microbiologist
Microbiology Consulting, Hazard Analysis and
Critical Control Points (HACCP), CGMP, and Validations
for the Food, Cosmetic, Nutritional Supplement, and Pharmaceutical Industry
enigl@aol.com
http://members.aol.com/enigl/index.html
March 15, 1997
5:02 am
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Fri Nov 01 2002 - 14:44:16 MST