Notwithstanding the incoherence of large social collectives, certain individuals, for reasons of public choice, find it advantageous to attribute cognitive states to them. I like to make light of this with a little joke: "As a society," the politician said, "I have decided . . . ."
Comparative references to how cells make up bodies or how dots make up a photograph thus do not resolve the question at hand. Neither cells nor dots nor, for that matter, photos, entertain cognitive states. We individual humans do,
Ian Goddard wrote:
> So the question is: Is the photo an illusion?
> If yes, the collective entity is an illusion.
> If no, then the collective entity is real.
T.0. Morrow
t0morrow@aol.com
http://members.aol.com/t0morrow/T0Mpage.HTML