From: Eliezer S. Yudkowsky (sentience@pobox.com)
Date: Sat Jun 19 1999 - 21:04:27 MDT
hal@finney.org wrote:
>
> He seemed to lean towards what he called pan-proto-psychism, the notion
> that the world is full of specks of proto-consciousness. This is an
> actual physical phenomenon which, when put together in the right way,
> produces consciousness. Perhaps this is consistent with Eliezer's
> noncomputational views.
Actually, it isn't - I considered that and discarded it back when I was
trying to figure out how to compute qualia. The problem is that if you
removed the specks of proto-consciousness, everyone would act the same.
The basic operations of a computer don't "act" on proto-consciousness,
they act on data. In my model, if you shut off a human's qualia, ve
would go into a coma or, more likely, just keel over and die.
Chalmers has a simple code to describe our positions. Chalmers codes
contain three letters; each letter is C, computational, P, physical, N,
neither. The code describes what it would take to simulate, produce,
and explain consciousness. Dennett is CCC; computation simulates,
produces, and explains consciousness. Searle is CPP; computation can
simulate consciousness, but not produce or explain it. Chalmers is CCN;
computation can simulate and produce consciousness, but not explain it.
Penrose (and Yudkowsky) are PPP; physical laws simulate, produce, and
explain consciousness.
My position is simple: No Zombies. Only single-letter codes are
logically consistent. Every facet of consciousness we can notice, that
we can *have a need to explain*, obviously influences our physical
actions. If there's any quality of consciousness that doesn't influence
our actions, nobody has ever written a paper about it. When you
perfectly simulate something, you have explained everything about it and
produced everything that exists in it.
Likewise, anything that affects our actions is a part of the laws of
physics, and a physical theory that doesn't include it will be incomplete.
There are only two logically consistent positions: CCC and PPP.
--
sentience@pobox.com Eliezer S. Yudkowsky
http://pobox.com/~sentience/tmol-faq/meaningoflife.html
Running on BeOS Typing in Dvorak Programming with Patterns
Voting for Libertarians Heading for Singularity There Is A Better Way
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Fri Nov 01 2002 - 15:04:15 MST