From: Freespeak (f-prime@activist.com)
Date: Thu Jan 28 1999 - 15:40:10 MST
OK, Ian. My paraphrasing: You see a difference between
"constellation" and "galaxy" in that the former is
a collective entity defined by an arbitrarily selected
number of stars you regard as ordered when viewed
from a particular angle or point of view.
To someone who has seen pictures or images of a
galaxy, a galaxy would be seen as a galaxy, no matter
from what angle or viewpoint the galaxy is seen
(except perhaps when the viewer is somewhere within
that galaxy). Could we describe a galaxy as an
"objective collective entity?"
Does your notion of a "constellation-type collective
entity" imply that if anyone were to define a number
of arbitrarily selected units and regarded them as
somehow ordered, then this definition, arbitrary
selection, and idea of order would bring about the
existence of a collective entity?
Frederick Mann
At 03:36 PM 1/28/99 -0500, Ian Goddard <Ian@Goddard.net> wrote:
>
>At 12:19 PM 1/28/99 -0700, Frederick Mann wrote:
>
>>> Clearly, no problem or logical confusion with the
>>> definition of "collective entity" as "the ordering
>>> of individuals in a system" as been demonstrated,
>>> which isn't to say that a problem can't be found.
>>
>>Can you see a fundamental difference between "galaxy"
>>on the one hand, and "constellation" on the other?
>
>
> IAN: A constellation is a collective entity
> defined by an arbitrary selection of ordered
> stars based upon a given point of view. A
> galaxy is also a collective entity defined by
> an ordering of stars, however, this ordering
> isn't arbitrary or based upon a given point
> of view, but may be caused by a black hole.
>
-- -------------------------------------------------------------- Best Freedom Site on the Web - <http://www.buildfreedom.com/>. Freedom/Liberty Portal - <http://www.buildfreedom.com/ft/>. Freedom & Financial Independence Lists - <http://www.buildfreedom.com/ourlists.htm>. --------------------------------------------------------------
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Fri Nov 01 2002 - 15:02:57 MST