From: Joe E. Dees (jdees0@students.uwf.edu)
Date: Thu Nov 19 1998 - 16:34:07 MST
Date sent: Thu, 19 Nov 1998 19:00:02 -0330
From: Bernard Hughes <bjhughes@istar.ca>
To: extropians@extropy.com
Subject: Differences - was Re: >H gender apartheid and transhumanists
Send reply to: extropians@extropy.com
>
>
> Joe E. Dees wrote:
>
> > >Bernard Hughes wrote
> > >
> > >
> > > Seems to me the significant word is "significant". I would consider someone a
> > > racist who believes the differences in races are sufficient to stereotype
> > > individuals behavior. e.g..
> > >
> > > "You are Asian, you must be good at Maths". "You are black, you must be stupid".
> > >
> > > I think few racial differences are significant in that sense. Only one case
> > > springs to mind where it might be valid to treat individuals differently based on
> > > race. That is in testing for certain heritable genetic diseases. I'm hard pressed
> > > to think of racial differences that are not swamped for the individual by
> > > environmental factors and personal genetic variation.
> > >
> > > Bernard
> > >
> >
> > Does this also hold for gender differences (verbal vs. visuo-spatial
> > cognitive styles, etc.)?
> >
>
> I can think of plenty of cases where gender does make a difference. But on many
> traits, the differences seem overrated. For example, height. Males are on average
> slightly taller than females. But if I were to tell you "You will shortly meet two
> people. One is a native Thai adult male, raised in Thailand. The other is a native
> Masai woman, raised in East Africa". You would lose money (on average) betting that the
> male will be taller. Other factors swamp the gender bias.
>
> It seems our brains amplify the significance of small average differences. We go from,
> "men are on average taller than women" to " men are taller" to "couples in which the
> man is shorter are weird". This kind of social logic may have had some survival value
> to our ancestors. However, I think it makes the kind of diverse society I would like to
> live in less likely, so it is a thought process I try to resist.
>
There are other differences less politically incorrect to note, such as
the ability to lactate, inseminate or gestate. There do seem to me
differences of cognitive style, also, which was the thrust of my
previous post and which you failed to address. Joe
> --
> Bernard J Hughes bernard@timedancer.com
> Timedancer Systems http://www.timedancer.com
> -- Creative Laziness at its best --
>
>
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Fri Nov 01 2002 - 14:49:48 MST