From: Dan Clemmensen (Dan@Clemmensen.ShireNet.com)
Date: Wed Sep 03 1997 - 16:19:21 MDT
Rick Knight wrote:
>
> For instance, in the area of Crop Cirlces, about which I know
> relatively little, it is an intriguing notion to think that they might
> be communications (such as those suggested in the film "Contact"). A
> scientific mind may seek to discredit crop circles as hoaxes by
> pointing out the "proof" that they are man-made. In my mind, that
> doesn't take into account a number of variables, many, alas,
> metaphysical in nature and thus, likely discreditable under classic
> scientific scrutiny.
>
> However, I consider that the circles, whether they be hoaxes done by
> clever humans or cryptic messages from an advances off-world race, to
> be a fascinating phenomenon, at least archetypally and sociologically.
> Some "hoaxes" are deliberate, confessed after the fact to be so, not
> to discredit but to continue a dialog in earnest. The human-made
> circles I'm told are often done with the utmost reverence, employing
> sacred geometry, considering time and location thoughtfully and
> planned out for months in advance.
>
> One might say that such an elaborate hoax and expenditure of time is
> all for naught. But even the effect it has on the different camps of
> thought on the legitmacy of crop circles is a fascinating byproduct
> for it "shakes the tree of knowledge" so to speak. Whether it
> provokes with fascination or irritates and divides groups of
> discussion, it has its place.
>
> The real world of qualified scientific phenomenon may well be utterly
> more fascinating than the more fanciful and supernatural notions
> sometimes expressed here but whether one outweighs the other in
> importance is up to the individual to decide. Science and imagination
> should be free to comingle and dance together to produce possibilities
> to come. I'll leave it to the moderators as to how to regulate a
> balance that doesn't abruptly dismiss or matter-of-factly discredit.
>
Rick, the book I completed most recently was "Contact" by Carl Sagan.
The book I'm reading now is "the Demon-haunted World", By Cark Sagan.
Sagan was very active founding member of CSICOP. These are scientific
skeptics. In addtion to the Sysiphyan taks of debunking pseudo-science,
they also publish scolarly research in the area of belief and its
psychology. I strongly urge you to read "the Demon-haunted world.",
which has quite a bit to say about crop circles. You may also wish to
join CSICOP and thereby receive their magazine, "Skeptical Inquirer",
which reports on these issues.
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Fri Nov 01 2002 - 14:44:48 MST