Re: >H Dilettantism

From: N.Bostrom@lse.ac.uk
Date: Mon Aug 19 1996 - 15:33:13 MDT


          Niklas Bostrom (alias "I") wrote:
          
>people who think they know something:they make very strong
>claims -and in many cases they don't even have a first
>degree in the subject!
          
          But this is not an academic journal, this is a mailing list
          for all sorts of people interested in transhumanism. We do
          not only discuss scientific questions, but also art, values,
          contemporary >H events etc. etc. The very diversity of the
          contributors adds to the fascination of the extropian and >H
          mailing lists. (And by the way, Niklas, you don't read most
          peoples messages, so what could you know!)
          
>we should work towards the degree of discipline and
>responsibility that characterise the top 20% of the
>acadacademic community
          
          I would make that "top 5%". Haven't you seen enough
          academics to realise how many narrow-minded fools there are
          at the universities. Even if we could persuade them that
          radical future technologies are worth thinking about, do you
          really believe that a person who need to be _persuaded_
          about that could have a significant capacity of judgement
          and would be able to contribute original ideas to the
          discussion of fundamental transhumanist issues?
          
>People in other "movements", especially our opponents, are
>often worse than we are. So what.
          
          Well, it gives us a justification for trying to spread our
          views. And for this we will need all our energy and
          enterprising drive, all the multifarious skills of the
          various persons on these lists. In truth, I tell you: the
          transhumanist movement is a boiling kettle, and amongst the
          steams I discern the shapes of a mighty spirit in the
          process of formation, an idea whose time has come...
          
          Niklas Bostrom n.bostrom@lse.ac.uk



This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Fri Nov 01 2002 - 14:35:43 MST