From: hibbert@netcom.com
Date: Tue Aug 28 2001 - 17:25:24 MDT
mlorrey@datamann.com said:
> Kuhn's theory was that all scientific theories are equally and
> subjectively valid, and one only gains credence over another due to
> class conflict between established scientists and the younger
> generations of scientists.
Is that in "The Structure of Scientific Revolutions"? That's sure not what
I learned from that book! Where is this part of his mindset exposed?
Have you read it, or are you repeating what other people have said? I'm
not trying to cast aspersions with this question. I want to know whether
you read the book differently than I did, or whether someone else did.
It's easy to believe that a deconstructionist might have read it that way,
for instance. If calm normal people also saw that, I'll have to re-read it.
Chris
---
Chris Hibbert protecting privacy in the computer age is
hibbert@netcom.com like trying to change a tire on a moving car.
http://discuss.foresight.org/~hibbert/home.html --Colin Bennett
Yahoo Instant Message: ag_cth
========================================
C. J. Cherryh, "Invader", on why we visit very old buildings:
"A sense of age, of profound truths. Respect for
Chris Hibbert something hands made, that's stood through storms and
hibbert@netcom.com wars and time. It persuades us that things we do may
last and matter."
http://discuss.foresight.org/~hibbert/home.html
Yahoo Instant Message: ag_cth
========================================
Chris Hibbert It is easy to turn an aquarium into fish soup, but
hibbert@netcom.com not so easy to turn fish soup back into an aquarium.
-- Lech Walesa on reverting to a market economy.
http://discuss.foresight.org/~hibbert/home.html
Yahoo Instant Message: ag_cth
========================================
Chris Hibbert Libertarians are to Freedom what
hibbert@netcom.com Quakers are to Peace. --John Stewart
http://discuss.foresight.org/~hibbert/home.html
Yahoo Instant Message: ag_cth
========================================
Chris Hibbert Computers are telescopes we use to see the infosphere.
hibbert@netcom.com Some care about telescopes, most want to see the stars.
Paraphrased from Gelernter
http://discuss.foresight.org/~hibbert/home.html
Yahoo Instant Message: ag_cth
Date: Tue, 28 Aug 2001 18:53:50 -0400
To: extropians@extropy.org
From: Mike Lorrey <mlorrey@datamann.com>
Reply-to: extropians@extropy.org
Subject: Re: Kuhn, was Re: new to list
hibbert@netcom.com wrote:
>
> mlorrey@datamann.com said:
> > If Newton had called it 'electromagnetic attraction', he would have
> > been wrong, and somebody else would have come up with the correct
> > theory of gravity. You seem to be suffering from a very Kuhnian
> > delusion that physical laws are created by people.
>
> I don't understand the attack on Kuhn. What is it in Kuhn (presumably "The
> Structure of Scientific Revolutions") that you connect to a "delusion that
> physical laws are created by people"? My reading of Kuhn was that it takes
> time for people (even scientists) to accept a fundamental change in our
> understanding of how reality works. I didn't think he had said that the
> world hadn't changed until the consensus had settled on the new view.
Kuhn's theory was that all scientific theories are equally and
subjectively valid, and one only gains credence over another due to
class conflict between established scientists and the younger
generations of scientists.
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Sat Nov 02 2002 - 08:10:12 MST