From: John Marlow (johnmarlow@gmx.net)
Date: Sat Jun 02 2001 - 04:42:04 MDT
#cbelow
On 1 Jun 2001, at 7:54, Chuck Kuecker wrote:
> At 12:31 AM 6/1/01 -0700, you wrote:
> >Windscale. Idaho Falls. Brown's Ferry. Three Mile Island. Chernobyl.
> >Who needs terrorists? Another Chernobyl seems far more likely.
> >
> >jm
>
> Chernobyl was a design for failure, and built without any kind of realistic
> containment. To top it all off, experiments to draw power from the energy
> stored in the graphite core were run while the cooling system was partially
> disabled.
#Again--second-rate nations will continue building second-rate crap
and using third-rate management which intentionally disables safety
devices.
...Along those lines, you forgot a couple of nuclear rocket
> experiments in Nevada that had fission products in the exhaust.
#Really? Do tell.
> Brown's Ferry proved that the safety systems work. Stupidity in using
> flammable wiring and a worker using a flame to check for air flow damaged
> the cabling, but the reactor remained safe. A success.
#Proved that the system failed. The design should never have been
approved; it had redundant flaws. It's a freaking miracle the thing
didn't melt down. HAte to see your idea of a failure, if this was a
success.
>
> Three Mile Island released no significant radiation to the environment. The
> containment worked.
#Prove it. Disabled detection devices is a wee bit suspicous,
wouldn't you say?
>
> We have the technology to produce SAFE reactors, if only someone will allow
> them to be developed. Again, I must bring up the IFR at Argonne Labs, that
> Clinton's administration killed off so efficiently.
#Yeah, we have the tech. Doesn't mean we can implement flawlessly.
>
> A really scary one that everyone ignores was the Fermi plant outside
> Detroit in the 1970's - a liquid sodium cooled fast breeder that actually
> had a meltdown due to last minute addition of "safety" devices not in the
> original plans. Check out the book "We Almost Lost Detroit".
#Hey, where do ya think I got the guy-pinned-to-the-ceiling story?
:)
jm
>
> Chuck Kuecker
>
>
>
John Marlow
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Sat Nov 02 2002 - 08:07:54 MST