Message-ID: <298ab7b97f0f34b6ef0e4b8345a942b3d77296d5.camel@federici.tech>
From: Michele Federici <michele@federici.tech>
Reply-To: michele@federici.tech
To: bitcoin-dev@lists.linuxfoundation.org
Date: Fri, 19 Apr 2019 13:53:51 +0200
Content-Type: multipart/signed; micalg="pgp-sha512";
	protocol="application/pgp-signature"; boundary="=-8Pm9ys6tD2ASbMthVz2o"
User-Agent: Evolution 3.30.5-1 
MIME-Version: 1.0
Subject: [bitcoin-dev] Using the same public keys,
 the p2sh returned by `addmultisigaddress` differs from the one
 returned by `createmultisigaddress`
Precedence: list


--=-8Pm9ys6tD2ASbMthVz2o
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="UTF-8"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable

Hi everyone,

I'm writing here because I didn't find any resources in the docs or
somewhere else online explaining this, I don't get if this is a bug or
I'm missing something.

I was working on a function to derive the pay-to-script-hash from a
multisig script and I was checking the results against the bitcoin
core's `addmultisigaddress` output, although I was quite sure that my
implementation was correct, my output address was different.
By chance, I then tried the `createmultisigaddress` method, using the
same public keys, and this time the output was matching with mine.

I thought the outputs of `addmultisigaddress` and
`createmultisigaddress` were supposed to be the same, but instead are
inconsistent from each other:

```
bitcoin-cli addmultisigaddress 1
'["045897fee25bd7c5692510b2f50fcae9aa20fbc4d49d59814f4c7fdb5c4bc6eb1c0c
e382458f9588e922e0d509ed8d34856787380075b00418b02e0bf7c652ef9d","02ac46
c6d74d15e60f4f1035ff07ef740aca1d68d55ba0b8d336a73d7a35858831","0224a4dc
5620714a9ecf67a09583d1e4c04f5bedb8ecea99028da05bb15a2a7e07"]'
{
"address": "36ULucjWUTrDvaJzCyhFoVbDoNS6Zum2Du",
"redeemScript":
"5141045897fee25bd7c5692510b2f50fcae9aa20fbc4d49d59814f4c7fdb5c4bc6eb1c
0ce382458f9588e922e0d509ed8d34856787380075b00418b02e0bf7c652ef9d2102ac4
6c6d74d15e60f4f1035ff07ef740aca1d68d55ba0b8d336a73d7a35858831210224a4dc
5620714a9ecf67a09583d1e4c04f5bedb8ecea99028da05bb15a2a7e0753ae"
}
```

```
bitcoin-cli createmultisig 1
'["045897fee25bd7c5692510b2f50fcae9aa20fbc4d49d59814f4c7fdb5c4bc6eb1c0c
e382458f9588e922e0d509ed8d34856787380075b00418b02e0bf7c652ef9d","02ac46
c6d74d15e60f4f1035ff07ef740aca1d68d55ba0b8d336a73d7a35858831","0224a4dc
5620714a9ecf67a09583d1e4c04f5bedb8ecea99028da05bb15a2a7e07"]'
{
"address": "3GiimyxF1R5VixfBFAbQZbuy9EesD2r6n1",
"redeemScript":
"5141045897fee25bd7c5692510b2f50fcae9aa20fbc4d49d59814f4c7fdb5c4bc6eb1c
0ce382458f9588e922e0d509ed8d34856787380075b00418b02e0bf7c652ef9d2102ac4
6c6d74d15e60f4f1035ff07ef740aca1d68d55ba0b8d336a73d7a35858831210224a4dc
5620714a9ecf67a09583d1e4c04f5bedb8ecea99028da05bb15a2a7e0753ae"
}
```

I was also pretty confused by the fact that the `redeemScript` is the
same, only the addresses are different, and calling `decodescript` with
it I get the same address as `createmultisig`:

```
bitcoin-cli decodescript
"5141045897fee25bd7c5692510b2f50fcae9aa20fbc4d49d59814f4c7fdb5c4bc6eb1c
0ce382458f9588e922e0d509ed8d34856787380075b00418b02e0bf7c652ef9d2102ac4
6c6d74d15e60f4f1035ff07ef740aca1d68d55ba0b8d336a73d7a35858831210224a4dc
5620714a9ecf67a09583d1e4c04f5bedb8ecea99028da05bb15a2a7e0753ae"
{
"asm": "1
045897fee25bd7c5692510b2f50fcae9aa20fbc4d49d59814f4c7fdb5c4bc6eb1c0ce38
2458f9588e922e0d509ed8d34856787380075b00418b02e0bf7c652ef9d
02ac46c6d74d15e60f4f1035ff07ef740aca1d68d55ba0b8d336a73d7a35858831
0224a4dc5620714a9ecf67a09583d1e4c04f5bedb8ecea99028da05bb15a2a7e07 3
OP_CHECKMULTISIG",
"reqSigs": 1,
"type": "multisig",
"addresses": [
"12PfkcWheYsfFddWfHhaXpFDVx78gnKQ9k",
"1AYLXzXd6N2avqW4j8Gyhb8jb2jXvNPyuV",
"1PWsxtcBMRHTSX2L7wrXgwnFigHD3KhbFT"
],
"p2sh": "3GiimyxF1R5VixfBFAbQZbuy9EesD2r6n1"
}
```

I don't understand, how can this be possible?

Thank you,
Michele

--=-8Pm9ys6tD2ASbMthVz2o
Content-Type: application/pgp-signature; name="signature.asc"
Content-Description: This is a digitally signed message part
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----

iQEzBAABCgAdFiEE8LpnnP1O6lVY/D5FTcim1Buz1vgFAly5ts8ACgkQTcim1Buz
1vg/yAf8CtrM6NKtUyEZEnQEg2QLONJO8zx+sJDhzBranxgIlpqxxLS6sWIqAwjP
gNyiQKwNa9e0hWBinUWyVXQIl/s9xmX7P2cOVtCQ8T4tyfyy285ALBCJ1rSKuAWG
4eDtqAwzjd9xyJ0Q8wAdxHf53SvjF01Qdj0HFfMWCF7Xm74kDqZ/oWWClxivGPfC
va+hnnuFhhxkoCxejkBRQUUJH7QnT0cE+BGT2D2Dj+Odj2pXcXdFK39qHrkZc62Y
zpXbXIGlXB0QWIVVsHfw/3iw69iAxY9pOEgbDlLMmpjgFMlu5a+p0O2phbLOEoas
ZbRlYIjYbjDuP8VdREWWvHao2ckjFA==
=AZ1Z
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

--=-8Pm9ys6tD2ASbMthVz2o--